James Franklin and Penn State: The Harsh Reality of Falling Short in Big Games

James Franklin’s tenure at Penn State has been defined by consistency, passion, and a winning culture—but also by a glaring inability to close out the biggest matchups. Despite years of success, the Nittany Lions continue to stumble when facing elite competition, leaving fans frustrated and critics armed with undeniable statistics.

Penn State’s Ongoing Struggle Against Top-Ranked Opponents

Saturday night in State College, the pattern repeated itself. Penn State lost 30–24 in double overtime to Oregon, a team ranked in the Associated Press Top 6. It wasn’t a one-off heartbreak. Under Franklin, the Nittany Lions have now dropped 15 straight games against AP Top 6 opponents, holding a dismal 2–21 record in such matchups—the second-worst mark in FBS history for a coach with at least 20 games against top-tier foes.

The loss to Oregon joins a list of disappointments that includes Michigan, Ohio State, and Notre Dame. Swap the helmets and logos, and the outcome remains the same: Penn State simply can’t win the biggest games.

Franklin Accepts Responsibility—but Facts Remain

“I get that narrative, and it’s really not a narrative—it’s factual,” Franklin admitted postgame. “We’ve got to find a way to win those games. I take full responsibility.”
His ownership of the situation resonates with players and fans alike, but accountability alone doesn’t change the scoreboard.

A Record of Success Overshadowed by Big-Game Failures

Franklin’s broader résumé is undeniably impressive. Since arriving in Happy Valley, he has compiled a 104–43 record, including six double-digit win seasons and a College Football Playoff semifinal berth. Three consecutive 10-win campaigns underscore his ability to build a powerhouse program. Yet each loss to a Top 6 opponent magnifies the glaring gap between being great and being elite.

Why 2025 Felt Different—Until It Didn’t

Heading into the Oregon showdown, all signs suggested Penn State was ready to break the curse:

• Dominant Early Season: The Nittany Lions annihilated their first opponents by a combined 132–19, winning every game by at least 30 points—a feat achieved only four times in school history.
• Home-Field Frenzy: Beaver Stadium was electric, filled to near-record capacity well before kickoff for the famed White Out.
• Experienced Roster: Quarterback Drew Allar entered with another year under his belt, while returning stars and a revamped wide receiver corps boosted offensive expectations.
• Coaching Moves: Franklin even lured defensive coordinator Jim Knowles from Ohio State to strengthen the defense.

Despite these advantages, none of it mattered. The offense started sluggishly, putting the team behind the chains on early downs and allowing Oregon to control the game.

Déjà Vu in Overtime

Penn State’s late rally forced overtime, but Allar’s interception in the second extra period sealed the loss. The play was a painful echo of last year’s season-ending turnover against Notre Dame, reinforcing the narrative that the Nittany Lions tighten up when the stakes are highest.

Fans Voice Their Frustration

As Oregon extended its lead to 17–3, the tension inside Beaver Stadium boiled over. Chants of “Fire Franklin” briefly rang out from the student section, reflecting a growing impatience with near-misses and almosts. Though the team clawed back, the result only deepened the frustration.

The Emotional Aftermath

After the final whistle, Franklin embraced his players, Oregon head coach Dan Lanning, and his own daughter, Addy. The poignant moment of father and daughter walking hand-in-hand through the blue-lit tunnel captured the human side of a coach under immense pressure—loved by many, questioned by others.

The Elusive Leap from Great to Elite

College football’s toughest jump is from greatness to true elite status. Penn State has the facilities, talent, and fan support to contend for national titles, yet that final step remains elusive. As Franklin himself knows, the facts don’t care about feelings. Until Penn State proves it can beat the very best, the shadow of those 15 straight Top 6 losses will linger over every victory.

Read our previous post about Pro Golfer Jake Knapp Mourns the Death of Girlfriend

Looking Ahead for Penn State Football

The Nittany Lions remain a perennial Big Ten contender with a foundation most programs envy. But if Franklin wants to quiet the critics and rewrite the narrative, he must find a way to win the matchups that matter most—games against the Michigans, Ohio States, and Oregons of the college football world.

For now, the record speaks louder than the effort. And in college football, effort without results keeps you on the outside of the championship picture looking in.